I am not entirely comfortable with notions of an exaggerated patriotism
that uses the symbols of a nation state. We are in a rapidly shrinking
globalised world where my aspiration would be for a borderless, nationless
inter-dependent planet. Having said that I think it is important that these
symbols as they exist, such as the flag, belong to all citizens. Respect for
them must be evoked by the state, not imposed.
Rajiv Mehrotra, filmmaker
Can the tricolour not represent the triumvirate controlling the cycle of
birth, life and death? The green symbolizes Lord Brahma - the eternal
creator of all living forms while the white stands for God Vishnu - the
supreme sustainer and controller of all the living beings. In saffron
manifests Lord Shiva - the Lord of destruction, the destroyer of evil. Can
this cycle go on without any of their interventions?
Can we, as a nation, progress without any of the qualities embodied in our
tricolour?
Ranjana Gauhar, artist
Children are less disillusioned, less cynical, less defeated than adults.
Theirs is a state of hope, of buoyant optimism; their lives are ahead of
them, spaces of possibility. To that extent, they are more likely to have
patriotic feelings. It is important that this patriotism is not translated
into a mindless jingoism as they grow older; and that they realise that it
is not the abstract idea of a nation, but rather, the pulsing reality of
human lives, citizens, people, that they must attend to.
***
There is no reason why the National-Flag
should be reserved for the use of dignitaries and state officials. It
signifies the emotional and political investment of millions of citizens,
and is therefore pre-eminently their symbol. It is faintly absurd,
therefore, that they should be denied the right to display it. At the same
time, we must recall that the flag is a symbol of greater realities; and
that, therefore, we must not become fixated on the symbol to the point of
forgetting the drama of human need and vulnerability, the mandates of
sacrifice and duty, the values of compassion and serenity that the flag
enshrines.
***
The colours of the flag remind me of
self-sacrifice, tranquility, discipline and fruitfulness. The
ethno-religious colouring that the flag has suffered is unfortunate: we
cannot afford to fight wars over saffron vs. green, blue wheel vs. white
band, if these elements are taken to embody different communitarian
interests.
***
I do not approve of the use of the
National-Flag on everyday items of clothing: a symbol of its exalted status
must be allowed to remain, to some extent, inviolate. Citizens must exercise
their discretion, in the matter of how to deploy the flag in their daily
lives.
Ranjit Hoskote, poet and art critic
The Indian tricolour is a beautiful flag. I have had many close
associations with it in my 75-year career by performing on India's
Independence Day and Republic Day in various parts of the world. I don't
think it is appropriate that the National-Flag is fashioned into a bikini or
a t-shirt as is common in some countries.
Pandit Ravi Shankar, sitar maestro
In 1973 I was part of a large Indian delegation participating in the 10th
World Youth Festival at Berlin and got the unexpected honour of being the
flag bearer of the Indian delegation at the inauguration ceremony. I was so
excited that I hardly slept the previous night. In the morning I was
aflutter inside, reducing into a jelly with every passing moment. Too many
issues kept crowding my mind. I hope I hold the flag pole right; I hope I
lower it at the right time for the ceremonial greeting before the
Presidential dais; I hope I maintain the proper distance with other
delegations ahead of us in the queue.
After what seemed an eternity, the inauguration ceremony started. As I took
the flag and held it aloft, I had goose pimples all over and as the
tri-colour fluttered gaily in the air, in rhythm with our Anthem, my eyes
filled with tears of joy and pride! We were proud to be Indians and proud of
our motherland.
What is it about a flag that makes one's heart beat faster and brings a
lump to the throat? As individuals, there is an innate hunger to 'belong'
and to have a 'sense of belonging'. It is here that the flag fills that need
by providing the much-needed symbol. For a citizen of any country, the
design and colours of the flag carry their own special significance. And so
is it with ours.
The sacrifices made by my grandfather and my maternal uncles who laid down
their lives in the freedom movement had not gone waste for though they
themselves were not here to witness the tricolour flying freely, however
what they died for, had become a reality and we were enjoying its fruits. I
also thought to myself that patriotism cannot be taught; it has to be felt
and experienced within for it is purely an emotional matter. Respect, pride
and honouring one's mother and motherland, comes from the heart!
Just then, a strong wind made the flag flutter to such an extent that there
was danger of the pole slipping from my hand. An unbidden thought entered my
mind. What if the pole fell down and my feet stamped on it? I shuddered
inwardly at the thought for it represented my motherland and could I ever
think of stamping on my mother? As a dancer, I was used to take leave of the
ground, the 'bhoomi' before starting my performance, asking 'leave' of
mother Earth. Fortunately nothing of that sort happened and later I kissed
the flag softly before handing it over. That day was one of the most
memorable days of my life!!
Shovana Narayan, Kathak danseuse
Using the flag in a degrading manner is a matter of shades and needs to be
figured out. For someone putting the flag on the t-shirt is degrading but
for someone else it may not be and these are bound to be contentious and
controversial issues. But I would rather take the controversial stuff in the
stride than have the flag restricted to 15th August or the President or some
VIPs only.
Dr. Sudhir Kakar, psychologist and author